Recent statistics state that over 50% of all
marriages in the United States will end in divorce. The statics also suggest the divorce rate is even
higher if there is a family business involved.
As for farms, some experts opine that more farms will be lost to divorce
in the coming decade than were lost in the 1980’s farm crisis. Safe to say we probably all know of someone
who married a farmer, married into a farm family, or started farming with their
spouse, only to find out later on farming was not all it appeared to be.
Without a doubt, a farm
divorce can decimate a farming operation.
Many states have divorce laws that essentially split the assets 50-50
between a husband and a wife. That means, with the stroke of judge’s pen,
half the farm can be gone. From there, the remaining half is unable to
sustain itself and the farm collapses.
Factor in other aspects such as capital gains tax for having to sell and
so forth, and you can see that the parade of horrible continue to roll right along.
What can be done to
keep a farm from being devastated by a farm divorce? Well, for starters,
a prenuptial agreement can greatly help. This is an agreement that spells
out various terms and conditions that will govern a divorce between a husband
and wife. It is sort of like a rule book
that spells out what happens should the couples decide to go their separate
ways. Without a doubt, you’ve likely
heard all sorts of urban and rural legends about prenuptial agreements. Be it as it may, these agreements, if done
properly, arise to an enforceable contract that should hold up in court.
Second, depending on the state you are in,
you can even enter into a post nuptial agreement where terms and conditions are
agreed to after the marriage has started.
In other words, an agreement is generated after the parties have been married that lays out various rules
should a divorce arise.
Third, using an LLC or trust can also be
effective. If one generation gifts or transfers to another, having an LLC
or trust can be very helpful in protecting assets in case there is a
divorce. Older generations should always
err on the side of caution when gifting or transferring assets to the younger
generation that could walk on down the road via a divorce. So, utilizing a corporation, LLC, or trust is
a good safety precaution.
So what happens when none of the above stated
techniques are utilized and a divorce occurs?
First, it is important to remember that farming is a business. When two people decide they no longer want to
conduct business with each other (i.e. stay married), there is a carry over to
the actual business (i.e. the farm) that needs to be addressed. Generally, at least one of the parties
desires to carry on the farm. This can
be tough if the other party wants cashed out of half the farm assets but the
other party wants to keep farming. In other
words, it is pretty hard to keep a farm intact when half of the assets may be
walking on down the road.
However, if the parties are willing to work
together, there is no need to kill the golden goose. I’ve seen divorce agreements entered into
where the farm stays intact, and the both parties continue to receive benefits
from the farm operation. Generally, a
well crafted trust or other type of arrangement will be needed. In any event, just because a husband and wife
have decided to stop doing business together in the form of marriage does not
necessarily mean they can no longer share ownership in a farm business. Simply stated, if the parties are willing to
set personal feelings and animosity aside, and focus on what makes business
sense, a lot can get accomplished and keep the farm intact.
It is important to remember that farm divorce
can rival any natural disaster or other terrible infliction onto a farming
operation. A little bit of planning will likely go a long way in
protecting the farm should a farm divorce occur. Once the farm divorce
horse has left the barn, there still is time to work so as to keep the farm
intact. However, it will take willingness
from both sides to strike the appropriate agreement so as to keep the farm
intact.
John J. Schwarz, II, is a lifelong farmer
and has been an agricultural law attorney for 12 years. He can be reached at
260-351-4440, john@schwarzlawoffice.com, or visit him at www.farmlegacy.com.
These articles are for general informational purposes only and do not constitute an attorney-client relationship.